Sunday, 20 April 2014

Exeter v Torquay preview: One More Big Performance Needed

With victory sending Torquay down and all but guaranteeing our League status, a lot more than bragging rights are at stake in this Devon Derby.


City have plenty to build on following Friday's impressive point at high-flying Chesterfield. Whilst Danny Coles' reintroduction went down like a lead balloon, the skipper was solid at the back, and it was only for a Danny Butterfield conceded penalty that the Spireites got something out of the game.

John O'Flynn started up top on his own, a decision Paul Tisdale must have regretted when the Irishman missed a sitter at 1-0. Tom Nichols was given much-needed time to recharge his batteries, though, and surely the City star will be back leading the line against Torquay.

Another who will hopefully be given the nod is young David Wheeler. The winger will relish the prospect of running at cumbersome Gulls centre-back Aaron Downes, as he did to such success at Plainmoor. Let's hope Tis' gives him an opportunity to do it again.

One of our weak spots for me this season has been our fullbacks. Both Butterfield and Woodman lack the pace and technical ability that City fullbacks of old used to strengthen attacks. Whilst Butterfield is solid defensively, I hope Tisdale opts for the more attacking option of Aaron Dawson. Remember how well he and Wheeler linked up during the brilliant Under-21 cup run of earlier in the season.

Whilst it's been a mostly forgettable campaign for the Grecians, particularly at home, spare a thought for the Torquay fans who are looking up where North Ferriby is for next season. It's a village north of the Humber, by the way...

The Gulls' demise began when Martin Ling was put on sick leave in February last year. The former City man has recently revealed that depression was the cause. Alan Knill took the reigns on an interim basis and successfully avoided relegation ...but only just. 

Knill was appointed full-time when Ling was dismissed for footballing reasons by Thea Bristow after the club "just escaped relegation" - despite Ling having nothing to do with their slide from mid-table. The former Scunthorpe boss continued his dodgy record in the first half of the season, with his side winning just five games, leaving them in the drop zone. After back-to-back Devon Derby defeats, enough was enough for the Yellows' board and Knill was sent packing.

Former Gulls' captain Chris Hargreaves, who I 4-1 think will remember the last time he faced the Grecians, was appointed as Knill's successor. The rookie manager has struggled to make an impact though, and Torquay are all but certain to be playing non-league football once again next season. They won't give up the fight until it's mathematically impossible, however, so City will have to play well to preserve their 100% Devon Derby win-rate.

If ever there was a need for a rare home win, it's here. Three points are vital as high-flying Scunthorpe, still unbeaten under Russ Wilcox, are next up. Let's hope come 5pm we'll be celebrating survival and replicating the 'We'll Meet Again' scenes made famous against Argyle back in 2011.


Prediction: Exeter 2-0 Torquay 

Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Derby Delight as City ease relegation fears

Exeter City all but extinguished any lingering relegation fears and dented Plymouth Argyle's play-off hopes with a stylish 2-1 comeback victory at Home Park in the Devon Derby last night.

It capped a memorable few days for City boss Paul Tisdale, who came under increasing pressure with City dropping down the table, but he has masterminded back-to-back wins that many fans couldn't have dreamt of following the season-low home defeat to Northampton.

Argyle were the side to take the lead in the derby, however. City captain Danny Coles, who impressively intercepted a number of crosses early on, undid his good work by deciding to block an out-of-reach cross with his hand - a straightforward penalty decision for referee Robert Madley. Reuben Reid duly converted from the spot for his 20th goal of the season, putting the home side in front on the stroke of half-time. A frustrating half for the travelling faithful as, despite some fine passing moves and dominating for large spells, Exeter were indecisive when getting in or around the penalty area.

After the break it was a largely similar story in terms of the balance of play, though City upped the tempo and started testing Argyle's defence more. On 58 minutes Paul Tisdale made the decisive substitution, replacing the hard-working Matt Gill with the more attack minded Matt Grimes. The youngster's introduction immediately added more pace to the midfield and his accurate forward passing meant that City began stretching the Pilgrims' back line. Not long later, the visitors' got the equaliser their play merited - Sercombe's long range effort took a wicked deflection, apparently off Tom Nichols' nose, and looped over the helpless Jake Cole.

With half-an-hour still to go, Exeter were in complete control. Richards went close after he was played in by Nichols immediately after the restart, and veteran midfielder Matt Oakley also spurned a good opportnity. Argyle were hanging on, but the pressure finally told on the 83rd minute - Tom Nichols turned brilliantly into the right-hand channel and played a perfectly weighted through ball into the path of strike partner Eliot Richards, who stroked home to the delirium of the away fans.

It was a marvellous second-half showing from the Grecians. Not only did they just outscore Argyle, they completely outplayed them. The slick passing football on show was in contrast to the home side's direct approach which increased upon the late introduction of Marvin Morgan.

City's homegrown trio were the star performers: Tom Nichols put in an Stanno-like display - quick, combative and tireless. The 20 year-old has been one of the few positives to come from this largely disappointing campaign and a new contract for Tom must be one of Paul Tisdale's main priorities in the summer.

Matt Grimes was typically impressive, whilst Liam Sercombe deserves plaudits for a much-improved display in the second-half which laid the foundations for the comeback.

Finally, a note in recognition of Tisdale's part in the win. Many were questioning him after the woeful run which saw the Grecians slump down the table, myself included, but the way in which City took charge after the interval oozed class. He won the tactical battle over John Sheridan, exploiting the hosts' 3-5-2 formation.

This win has lifted the doom that had descended on St James' Park. Once a few more points are on the board, hopefully on Saturday against Accrington, we can look ahead to next season with optimism knowing we have among our ranks some of the best young footballers in the division.

Wednesday, 12 March 2014

Grecians Sink to New Low

It was the same old sorry story for Exeter City last night - a narrow one goal defeat, no clean sheet and no goals scored. An all too familiar tale which has left many fans questioning whether Paul Tisdale has the fight and determination needed to spare the Grecians from the humiliating fate that will await them if improvements are not made.

Looking at Tisdale's record before and after the record-equalling 8th place finish in League One back in 2011 (right), you have to wonder if he is the man to rescue City from relegation to the awful sounding Skrill Premier. His stock has fallen sharply since the high point of that win at Hillsborough, and whilst the loyalty he showed by reportedly rejecting both Swansea and Southampton was admirable, should he have departed with his status as City's greatest manager secured?

After last night's defeat, Tis told the Western Morning News, 
“I thought the first half hour was excellent other than the fact we didn’t create chances or score goals." This is worrying as he seems to have forgotten the objective of the sport. Four wins and 15 goals at home is a pathetic return, and it's got to the state where we will ultimately have to rely on away points to stay up. How Guy Wolfenden can justify a rise in ticket prices next season is frankly laughable and an insult to those who have watched the dross at St James' Park this season. 

Let's hope our away form doesn't desert us for the run-in, because relegation back into the dark, depressing dungeon that is non-league football wouldn't just be embarrassing, but financially catastrophic. Just look at Hereford - following relegation in 2012, attendances at Edgar Street plummeted to last season's average of 
1,793. Not only that, but the Bulls recently announced that £65k was needed to fund the youth setup for next season. City's finances are rumoured to be far from healthy as it is, so relegation could put the future of the club, certainly under the current ownership, in serious doubt.

The Supporters' Trust setup has been questioned for a while now. Apparently 'We Own Our Football Club'. The real truth, however, is that the ridiculous number of non-football staff on the payroll are leaving a paltry sum for the playing budget, which has resulted in Tommy Doherty and Alan Gow departing SJP. The Trust should be held account for this, along with why the club has been so opaque with financial results.

Sunday's game at Newport is now crucial. Justin Edinburgh's side have collected even fewer points than City over the past eight games. If you can, get along to Rodney Parade and cheer on the team as they seek a win before a tough looking double-header against Fleetwood and Plymouth.

Thursday, 9 January 2014

January Sales: Tisdale’s best (and worst) mid-season signings

Steve Tully: After a short spell with the Grecians in 2005 which garnered just two appearances, it’s fair to say Tulls’ second stint at St James’ Park was more successful. The right-back quickly became a fan favourite for his gutsy performances and that penalty at Oxford, and although his crossing left much to be desired at times, (the shinned attempt into the Big Bank last season springs to mind) Tully’s defensive strengths meant that he was a mainstay of the side until his surprise departure at the end of the last campaign.

Ryan Harley: Or rather Sir Ryan Harley. I remember well the Tuesday night game against York on Setanta where Harley made his second appearance as a second-half substitute, though little did I know that one of the best players in modern times to grace the red and white had just arrived on the scene. His playmaking, passing and finishing were effortless – the coolest head on the pitch when he kept City in League One in 2010 - which makes it all the more bemusing that he was turning out for Weston Super-Mare prior to his City switch. After a couple of seasons at Brighton, Sir Ryan is now a part of Mark Cooper’s Swindon Town team.

Richard Logan: Ah, the wonderfully unpredictable Logie. At times he bullied defences with his aerial ability and finishing, but there were also the other, more forgettable performances. The two stooping headers to seal a trip to Wembley and promotion to League One will live long in the memory of City fans and I think it’s safe to say that he loved us as much as we loved him. Lo lo, lo… you know the rest.

Troy Archibald-Henville: Troy initially arrived at St James’ Park in 2009 on a six-month loan deal and immediately became a fan favourite for not only his excellent displays, but because his name fitted perfectly into pre-match tune ‘Seven Nation Army’. He was a deceiving player in that he had, as the old cliché goes, a good touch for a big man, so much so that he was used as a holding midfielder for a time. It was at centre-back alongside captain Matt Taylor where he was most at home, though, and it was no coincidence that the Grecians’ downward decline back to League Two began when that partnership was broken up. Troy was snapped up by nutcase Paolo Di Canio during his infamous reign at Swindon in 2011 and is still there today, under the more-straightforward management of Mark Cooper.

Mark Molesley: The central-midfielder enjoyed a loan spell at League Two minnows Plymouth Argyle last season, before City snapped him up from Bournemouth on a free transfer this time last year. Despite impressing in his first few games for the club, Molesley’s form nosedived along with that of the Grecians - epitomised by a woeful showing at former club Argyle. Released at the end of last season, he now turns out for Conference side Aldershot.

Luke O’Brien: Possibly Paul Tisdale’s worst signing to date. Left-back O’Brien arrived from Bradford to replace the Barnsley-bound Scott Golbourne ...except he didn’t replace him. Three inept displays in the red and white were enough for Tis to realise the mistake he’d made and O’Brien was unceremoniously released at the end of the fateful 2011-12 relegation campaign. After spending last season at Oxford, the 25 year-old now plies his trade for Gateshead.

Sunday, 5 January 2014

Sunday Scribble: Cup magic lives on

With 2014 in full swing, a new weekly column arrives on the blog. Each week, the hastily-named Sunday Scribble will look at the key talking points of the week from across the divisions.

Upsets galore as Big Sam and Lambert are left red-faced

The FA Cup returned to the centre stage this weekend, and what a refreshing change it made to the money-obsessed glitz and glamour of the Premier League. Six top-flight sides were knocked out, including Aston Villa. A relief for Villa boss Paul Lambert who said before the game that Premier League managers could do without the competition "if they were being honest". Lambert's comments soon backfired when he was jeered off following the 2-1 home defeat to League One strugglers Sheffield United. Sam Allardyce had a similarly forgettable weekend after his youthful West Ham side were stuffed 5-0 at Nottingham Forest, a performance that has left Hammers fans calling for Big Sam's sacking. Perhaps picking such an inexperienced side was not such a clever move after all, even with the Hammers' injury list being a substantial one.

There is now a split-opinion as to the importance of the Cup. To us the fans, the excitement of a knockout competition and the unpredictability that comes with it is why the FA Cup is so revered around the world. For managers and chairmen (Dave Whelan aside), however, the importance of remaining in the Premier League and taking their wedge of that ridiculous TV and sponsorship money matters more. Of course the FA could do more to help the Cup's cause - it's surely only a matter of time before replays will have to be scrapped. But to those like Paul Lambert who question the importance of the Cup, consider this: In 30 years from now what will a fan remember, winning the FA Cup or finishing 16th in the Premier League?

Moyes struggling to emerge from Fergie's shadow

Another of the FA Cup upsets was Swansea's surprise 2-1 win at Old Trafford... or was it a surprise? United suffered their second-straight home defeat as Wilfried Bony's late header dumped the Red Devils out of the competition, meaning their FA Cup drought goes on - it's now 10 years since they last lifted the famous trophy.

Succeeding the great Sir Alex was always going to be tough for David Moyes, but it hasn't been made any easier by, in Man United standards, the rather inferior squad he's been left with. Defensively they look shaky at times, with veteran Rio Ferdinand well past his prime. In midfield they are crying out for another holding midfielder and attacking midfielder - Arturo Vidal and Juan Mata have been mentioned as potential signings. Moyes I'm sure is more than aware that the January window is a time managers would ideally avoid at all costs due to the improbably of landing a quality player, but for the Scot new year business is imperative to simply stand any chance of finishing in the top four and to avoid this 'period of transition' turning into a disaster.

That isn't the end of Moyes' woes. Wayne Rooney's contract is up in 18 months time, and with Chelsea reportedly readying a £30m bid, securing the future of United's prized asset has to be high on the list of January business too.

Friday, 13 September 2013

New Signings Make Immediate Impact

Ten months is a long time in football. There have been managerial changes and transfers galore since the last post on this blog back in October. Not so much at Exeter City, though. Paul Tisdale still reigns supreme at the Cat & Fiddle, with the summer departures of Sir Alex, David Moyes and Tony Pulis pushing him up the LMA longest-serving managers list to behind only Arsene Wenger.

Despite the number of first team players who departed St James' Park last season, Tis was left with a meagre sum in which to strengthen his side. Nevertheless, the two players who did join the Cat & fiddle cavalry in pre-season - Sam Parkin and David Wheeler - have added much needed height and energy to a side which wilted so poorly at the end of last season.

Wheeler in particular has been a revelation since his summer switch from Staines Town. The 22 year-old's energetic, pacey bursts and impressive aerial ability mean he hasn't looked out of place either in a team that has made a good start to the season, the highlight of which being the vintage Brazil-like display against a lacklustre AFC Wimbledon, who were almost as bad as they were at the Park last season.

Parkin (foreground) and Wheeler (back left) in action at Yeovil Town.
Photo courtesy of Paul Sussex.
Most thought he would be slowly introduced to the side given his non-league background, but Tisdale, who has had great success recruiting from the lower echelons in the past (remember Ryan Harley and Matt Taylor?) obviously saw the same star quality in the unassuming 22 year-old. Some even say that Tis' limited Wheeler's appearances in the pre-season friendlies to prevent another side poaching him before City could offer him a deal.
We don't know if that is true, but what is clear is that City could have unearthed a gem.

Then we come to Sam Parkin, now at the 14th club in a career that has stuttered since a prolific spell at Swindon, where he earned the tag 'Super Sammy Parkin'. The past eight years have been less super for the 32 year-old, though, and after an mostly unsuccessful stint in Scotland, he returned south to join City.

The first few outings for Parkin in a red and white shirt have been promising. His dramatic winner against Bristol Rovers quickly endeared him to the City faithful and he nodded home his second goal to earn a point at Dagenham on Saturday.

Parkin offers a lot more than the occasional headed goal, however. He gives the Grecians an aerial presence upfront that they so obviously lacked last season, whilst being able to hold up the ball and bring others into play. If he can stay fit, which is so often the prerequisite with City's players, Parkin will prove a valuable asset throughout the season and beyond.

Monday, 29 October 2012

Cureton's Goals Sparing Grecian Blushes

He may be 37 and well into the 'twilight' of his career, but Jamie Cureton's goals are as important as ever.

The ever-reliable veteran forward has always known where the back of the net is, and that's a relief considering City's other forwards haven't exactly been forthcoming with goals this season.

When you take away every League goal 'Curo' has notched so far in the campaign, the Grecians are 12 points worse off, meaning they would be bottom of the League with a paltry eight points. That isn't surprising given Cureton has scored 10 of City's 21 League goals this season.

This wouldn't be such a problem if he was in his 20's, but unfortunately he's not, and the worry is that he could run out of steam if he continues to be played so frequently. If that were to happen, where would the goals come from?

I hope Tis, as well as working out why City concede a goal from virtually every cross and corner, is thinking up a solution. A dip in the loan market would be sensible. I was quite impressed with Lauri Dalla Valle's brief loan spell at the Park during last season's ill-fated campaign so he might be an option or alternatively (and preferably) our young forwards could be played more frequently.

Cureton may not necessarily run out of steam and suffer 'burnout', but if he does or picks up an injury it would intensify City's woes even further, so it's time for his fellow frontmen to step up to the plate or a new player may have to be drafted in.